TUFFR IN THE 501
TUFFR in the 501
Noun. Taxpayers United For Fiscal Responsibility in Central Arkansas
Used as a description of a group of real people dedicated to improving economic growth and quality of life for every 501 community and the citizens who live in themSunday, March 25, 2012
Here We Go Again Perhaps?
For me, it started with this quote I read in the 3/8 edition of the Arkansas Democrat Gazette attributed to a PCSSD Administrator named Paul Brewer.
It read " “If something happens and the union goes away, we have to have something else in place,” Brewer said about employee policies and a committee. “I think that if the union goes away, by law, you have to have a [personnel-policies committee]. So if the union goes away for whatever reason — and we are not advocating that — this would be a backup plan because you have to have a set of policies to go by, by law. If there is not a union, [policies] have to be approved and sent in to the state Education Department.”
I was at first, mildly amused then infinitely irritated and, finally, moved to take action by this comment. Every change in PCSSD administration brings hope the new Administrators are different and that they have the leadership skills and management knowledge their predecessors lacked to finally bring about progress and performance improvement. But the new administrative team appears to be doing precisely and predictably what their peers have done before them. Mr. Brewer's comment isn't the problem although the "I think that if the union goes away by law" is either a remarkably uninformed comment for a person in his position or remarkably disingenuous one if he knows what the end game really is. Actions however truly speak louder than words! The Personnel Policy Committees he referred to are already in place. This is the very same action the previous Superintendent and Board of Four took and wasted hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars on with one purpose in mind. Their intention was union breaking, to make the Pulaski Association of Classroom Teachers and the Pulaski Association of Support Staff disappear. What we as taxpayers got for their multiple trips to court was to hear the administrators repeatedly be told to follow the law. I don't know for certain that this is the intention of the new Superintendent and his team so here's what I plan to do right after I get the lawn mowed and a couple of other things done.
I am going to e-mail Mr. Brewer and the PCSSD Superintendent in the spirit of collaboration and ask them a few simple questions to make sure I got it straight. Here is what I'm going to most them in my most respectful typing tone.
Gentleman:
I was wondering if you could please help me and many other Central Arkansas citizens who Federal, State or local tax dollars fund your district's operations understand several actions your team have recently taken regarding establishing Personnel Policy Committees in the PCSSD.
1. What basis, rationale, policy, or other guidance are you using for establishing PPC's, particularly when you know PACT and PASS have met all of their obligations by law to be recognized as the collective bargaining representative for both of these employee groups?
2. What basis, rationale, policy, law, or other directive are you using to assume the current Professional Negotiated Agreements (PNA's) that were negotiated by and agreed to both parties can be ignored?
3. Why would you take any action that would necessitate spending any funds in the courtroom not the classroom, particularly when you are publicly stating the district is in dire financial distress? What will this do to increase the capacity of any building level educator or student to improve their performance. What is the "value" of this action in terms of money? The morale and well being of your teacher and support staff?
4. What research or other data are you using that shows "non union" districts out perform those that are "union" represented? In what ways does this appreciably improve teacher retention and job satisfaction? Student achievement? This is a particularly important question given the existence of a tremendous amount of data that seems to contradict that specific position.
By the way gentleman, I hope you don't mind if I ask you more questions as I learn more about the specifics about your budget and some rumored "contradictions" in one or more budget presentations that have been made. Please know I appreciate your time and assistance. Thank you!
Respectfully,
Dave Wheeler
Please feel free to join me asking these two gentleman to clarify their position so we don't mistakenly assume their sole purpose is UNION BUSTING TOO! You can use and modify my questions or add some of your own! In fact, feel free to share your questions or comments below.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I totally agree with everything that you have said. It seems absolutely moronic to me that folks out at the PCSSD central office continue to make the same stupid mistakes over and over again. Hundreds of thousands of dollars have been squandered on lawsuits that could have been totally avoided had someone out there with a lick of common sense taken a moment to read and follow a contract that was mutually agreed upon and signed by both parties. This is time and money that could have been better spent in the education of central Arkansas children. As a taxpayer, I am outraged that MY tax dollars are being thrown away so frivolously! In my opinion, Mr. Guess, Mr. Kimbrell, and (yes) even Mr. Beebe have some angry taxpayers (and VOTERS!) to answer to. Get your acts together and stop wasting my money!!!!!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the perspective and comments. SPEND IT IN THE CLASSROOM NOT THE COURTROOM! Please keep speaking out! I always go back to the Margaret Meade quote "A small group of thoughtful people could change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has." Thnks again!
DeleteDitto. Please ask why the district is paying for lawyers in negotiations and why they are providing lawyers for teachers that decided to form a PPC on their own!
ReplyDeleteI saw yesterday something that said they were ordered to pay some legal expenses for the Joshua Intervenors and who knows how many additional suits will be filed after the Attorney General's Deseg Funding filing. There is however one court filing I would like to see the PCSSD defend themselves again and that is a Taxpayer lawsuit over spending PCSSD funds to in a lawsuit they weren't even named in. I believe that is being researched. That is one thing that needs to be asked to Dr Kimbrell and the Governor. If they were using this as a Union Busting tactic, what's the point. Maybe they think they can pass it off as a charitable donation to a worthy cause! Really the only thing I get angry about is someone thinking I'm stupid. Thanks Dee for the comments and keep them coming please!
DeletePerhaps Mr. Guess could explain why there are two attorneys sitting in on district negotiations? There is an in-house attorney. Why isn't said attorney handling this? What about this attorney coming up from Camden? Guess's old stomping grounds. Sounds like the good old boy network milking the fat cow. I thought Guess was hired to reduce expenditures - not add to them!
ReplyDeleteNow that is an excellent question! Business and Common Sense 101 tells me that when you don't have the money to do the job you have THREE choices...Raise more, make the most of what you have by spending what you have on your most critical deliverables and on those things "produce them", or do both. Raising more doen't just mean money. Look at the concessions that PACT/PASS have already agreed to help. Look at the damage this always does to enrollments, and volunteer hours to name a few. I can't believe I am quoting Rahm Emanuel but I was reading an article where he talked of what they are trying to do in Chicago schools "YOU HAVE TO SPEND WHERE THE SERVICE MEETS THE CUSTOMER" Seems that would be in the Classrooms not the Court Rooms! Teachers and Support staff folks are much more essential that Administrators because they are dead square in the middle of the Intersection of Customer and Service. i GUESS the Dr. says he has cut two slots. I think we know where the rest is coming from. This is a Lose-Lose-Lose situation. A bad situation is made worse, taxpayers and communities lose, but those that suffer and lose the most are those at ground zero...the intersection of customer and service...the students. The kids the elected officials. the federal, state, local educrats say they care most about but were that true, why do their actions always say other wise? Let's ask them! Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Please keep doing so!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGood question about the PPC folks. First of all, it was a totally illegal election. PCSSD already has a PPC in place - it's called PACT. That is the body that works with district personnel to establish the personnel policies that govern teachers - those policies are in the negotiated contract! Additionally, there was absolutely no transparency in the "election" results. No oversight whatsoever.
ReplyDeleteThe fact that the district is providing lawyers for the people on these two PPC committees raises several pertinent questions. Not only is the district spending my tax dollars but they are perpetuating a situation that the court has already ruled on. Who is the ringleader here? I find it hard to believe that a handful of teachers who are busy doing their jobs all of a sudden decided that it was time to try for a PPC vote again! More likely the directive/suggestion (wink, wink) came from district administration and might even have come from higher up on the food chain. This is another violation of state law regarding PPCs.
So more tax dollars are being spent every day. These are dollars that could at least be put to use in a way that is advantageous to the students in the classroom and for use by the teachers who have face to face contact with them each day. Or maybe my taxes might even be reduced! There's a thought!
I would really like some honest answers here from Mr. Guess. Rather disingenuous, don't you think? He was more than willing to work with teachers - now, all of a sudden, he can't agree to or compromise on anything related to the teacher contract.
There is something rotten in Denmark.
Exceptional! PACT and PASS exist only because teachers and support staff support them. During the last go round with the previous Board and Superintendent, they received 1200 of 1400 votes cast to support them in spite of a 1000.00 per teacher finacial incentive one of the Board members put out there if they opted for a PPC. If they don't have the support of 50 percent plus one of the employee groups they represent, they lose their right to be the collective barginning group for those employees. I have been involved in PCSSD schools in some capacity I was stationed at Little Rock AFB in 1986. I can honestly say from first hand experience that BREAKING PACT AND PASS have always been on the agenda of the various Boards and Superintendent, some more visible than others. Goggle it...the archives tell the story! People really don't know that the national rhetoric isn't close even close to the local reality or talking points of groups who oppose them come contract time. PACT and PASS are labels. I support all teachers and support staff folks regardless of their member or non member. Collectively they have long been held responsible in the public eye...scape goated...for the never ending series of ineffective, and in some cases, arrogant and imcompetent Board members and administrators. They don't make or control programs and policy, decide where the money gets spent, or waste not a dime of it on Broadway shows, in town hotel stays, trips to China because speaking Mandarin is more important than having basic supplies and desks in schools. The Legislative Audit Reports, The State Department of Ed School Audits should be mandatory reading for all. If the Unions disappeared tomorrow...how would that change the quality of District Leadership? Particularly when they either don't know or ignore the fact that the folks who are truly the ones who have the greatest role to play in improving school performance are the very same teachers, parents, support staff, and community members they continue to alienate with their poor management and business practices. Best leadership advise I ever got was from a General I worked at LRAFB. He pointed out that I could have a building full of allies or a building full of enemies and that it was my actions that would decide which line they stood in. I'm thinking the new Administraors might o well by considering that point.
ReplyDeleteWhat great advice from that general!
ReplyDeleteHistorically, PCSSD administration has not looked out for teachers - those who are in the trenches facing the daily battles. Teaching children - young or old -is hard work! Teachers need support from a small administration - not to be constantly attacked by them.
I heard that since Guess was hired, ADDITIONAL staff has been hired on at the central office. Again, it was my understanding that he was supposed to REDUCE expenditures not increase them. Traditionally, those people are paid at a significantly higher salary than the teachers are paid.
Once again, one of the first places to pare expenses is at the district administration level. They should be there to serve teachers (facilitating teachers' efforts to educate children), not the other way around.
When you don't have enough you need to raise more, do better with what you have ,or do both of the preceding real well. After the all of the events leading up to the State Board taking the action they did, you would think one the immediate concerns would be rebuilding trust and engaging all stakeholders in setting the future direction the district will take. Transparency should be the order of the day. Why not schedule several public meetings to review the budget...item by item. Dr. Lester I believe did that and many still joke about the "big red binders". If/as more folks share our concerns, more people will ask the same questions, do the research, and try to get the facts. When schools excel, communities benefit. When they don't...not good for the taxpayers!
ReplyDeleteTransparency (versus subterfuge) would be extremely nice! The teachers' perception of "Us vs. Them" is not a good way to run a school district!
ReplyDeleteOr to get the folks who are really the ones who will really drive improvement in each school involved and engaged. I'm starting to hear folks talking about what the what the believe the real end game is, particularly after the Attorney General's filing on deseg funds. Given the number of PCSSD schools perennially listed as being in academic distress I'm not sure how you hope to make the case or why you even want to try if a quality and equitable education was the real issue. Great observation! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteaw SNAP....another informed person 'holding up the mirror'.....unfortunately the one being called out doesn't have a reflection!
ReplyDeleteInteresting! Given the lack of access the public has been given to speak with the Superintendent lately that could explain a lot. Thanks UnHombre...
ReplyDelete