TUFFR IN THE 501

TUFFR in the 501

Noun. Taxpayers United For Fiscal Responsibility in Central Arkansas

Used as a description of a group of real people dedicated to improving economic growth and quality of life for every 501 community and the citizens who live in them

Saturday, March 31, 2012

A Little Transparency Please!


I have always tried to listen to both sides of the story when it comes to these types of conflicts. One would think that should be easy to do.  You call/e-mail one group with a question then do the same to the other.  I will tell you from decades of experience that one side of the PCSSD debates is always willing to answer questions and share information.  The other, well, not so much. When all else failed, the last place I could go to seek information was the monthly School Board Meeting. The other day when I was looking at the PCSSD website I noticed link to School Board Meeting Minutes. I clicked on a few and the first thing I noticed which was Items 1 and 2 in the December Minutes. They said " Employee Benefits. The District reached an agreement with the Pulaski Association of Classroom Teachers and the Pulaski Association of Support Staff employees changing the way employee benefits are handled in the District effective April 1, 2012. This change will be a cost saving measure for the District. Approved
Additional Money for Employees. The District reached an agreement with the Pulaski Association of Classroom Teachers and the Pulaski Association of Support Staff employees that there would be no additional money given to employees of the District for the 2011-2012 school year. Approved. 

When the PCSSD had an elected Board, the monthly meetings were one opportunity where taxpayers, parents, patrons, whomever could speak directly to the Board and Administrators. Notifications of the meetings had to be sent out some 24 hours before I believe so folks had the option to attend. There is no doubt this process did not result in "transparency" regarding district operations and expenditures. It wasn't even translucent. Vague opaqueness perhaps could describe it.  One thing is for sure however is even the old way was better than the total eclipse on access to those making the decisions and information being used to make those decisions than is in place right now.  So I asked the question if these "Board" meetings were public.  The answer I received was no. The "Minutes" are available for review at the Central Office for several days and then sent to the State Dept of Ed.  Really?  If there is ever a group of  folks who deserved transparency in how there tax dollars were being spent is those of us whose federal, state, and local tax dollars are used in the PCSSD.  If these  aren't these so-called "School Board Meetings" aren't open to the public, why not?  As I understand it, Dr Kimbrell is the School Board.  He might not have a lot of company sitting in one of the big chairs beside him but I imagine he would have all kinds of company with lots of questions in the room with him. After all, community involvement is what educators are always telling us they want isn't it?

I do understand however that the next Arkansas Department of Education Board meeting is on Monday April 9th.  I would encourage everyone with a key board and internet connection to e-mail the Members of Arkansas Department of Education Board to ask for their help in bringing transparency and some modicum of accountability to the way the PCSSD is being managed.  The School Board Minutes clearly show that PACT/PASS have made concessions to help with the fiscal situation yet once again the spin coming from the PCSSD Administrators appears to once again to blame them for being unwilling to make concessions.  How can folks know for sure if the so called "deficit"is a result of an accounting tactic rather than a honest and accurate line item by line item of what the actual expense and balances are?  What budget figures did the District provide during the recent "fact finding" sessions in early March? Why doesn't the Arkansas Department of Education encourage Dr Kimbrell to conduct regular public meetings or at least one devoted to the budget similar to Dr. Lester's "Big Red Binder" meetings of in the mid 90's to "show us the money!" There are two sides to every story. Public "on the record" meetings are the only way we taxpayers have to hear both sides and make all parties in this situation accountable for how are tax dollars are spent. 

This link will to you to a page that has e-mail links for each State Department of Education Board Member.

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

EXCELLENCE in EVERYTHING? Absolutely!


And yes, that includes public schools and education reform. No, best make that especially in public schools. Here's "The Why"...

The gentleman above is Tom Peters.  He is perhaps best known for being the co-author of one best selling and most widely read business books on the planet "In Search of Excellence" and he remains one of the most influential and relevant voices on all things that create "EXCELLENCE". The two simple concepts he describes are exactly what are missing in the discussion of ow to fix schools.

Actually, what's missing in the discussion of education reform is actually the discussion.  It's not even a debate or argument.  What we have are actually parallel monologues of educrats (and their consultants) and educators who excel at pointing out why the other side is wrong. Neither however offer little or nothing in the way of solutions. The choice is a simple one.

I personally would be most interested in listening to the folks in leadership positions explain why they believe that continuing to do the same things that have wasted hundreds of millions of dollars over the past decades in additional Federal and State desegregation funds and have yet to be declared unitary is the best course of action to take.  Maybe they know something Mr. Einstein didn't about the insanity of doing the same thing and expecting a different result.  I would also like to ask you "What Do You Think" of the Four "F" Formula for Fixing Public Schools ™ the folks at PACT and I collaborated on back in the mid 90's.
  • Fund the Front Line First
  • Focus on the Fundamentals...as they relate to Pedagogy and Business Practices
  • Forget Fads and Fast Fixes
  • Form "High Performance" Partnerships
Looking forward to those discussions!

Oh, and Thank You Mr. Peters! I recall a quote that said "The problem with using simple language is that you have to know what you are talking about"  You have consistently proven that, not only do you know what you're talking about, you know how to make it work in the workplace!

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Here We Go Again Perhaps?


For me, it started with this quote I read in the 3/8 edition of the Arkansas Democrat Gazette attributed to a PCSSD Administrator named Paul Brewer.

 It read "  “If something happens and the union goes away, we have to have something else in place,” Brewer said about employee policies and a committee. “I think that if the union goes away, by law, you have to have a [personnel-policies committee]. So if the union goes away for whatever reason — and we are not advocating that — this would be a backup plan because you have to have a set of policies to go by, by law. If there is not a union, [policies] have to be approved and sent in to the state Education Department.”

I was at first, mildly amused then infinitely irritated and, finally, moved to take action by this comment. Every change in PCSSD administration brings hope the new Administrators are different and that they have the leadership skills and management knowledge their predecessors lacked to finally bring about progress and performance improvement. But the new administrative team appears to be doing precisely and predictably what their peers have done before them.  Mr. Brewer's comment isn't the problem although the "I think that if the union goes away by law" is either a remarkably uninformed comment for a person in his position or remarkably disingenuous one if he knows what the end game really is. Actions however truly speak louder than words!  The Personnel Policy Committees he referred to are already in place. This is the very same action  the previous Superintendent and Board of Four took and wasted hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars on with one purpose in mind. Their intention was union breaking,  to make the Pulaski Association of Classroom Teachers and the Pulaski Association of Support Staff disappear. What we as taxpayers got for their multiple trips to court was to hear the administrators repeatedly be told to follow the law. I don't know for certain that this is the intention of the new Superintendent and his team so here's what I plan to do right after I get the lawn mowed and a couple of other things done.

I am going to e-mail Mr. Brewer and the PCSSD Superintendent in the spirit of collaboration and ask them a few simple questions to make sure I got it straight. Here is what I'm going to most them in my most respectful typing tone.

Gentleman:

I was wondering if you could please help me and many other Central Arkansas citizens who Federal, State or local tax dollars fund your district's operations understand several actions your team have recently taken regarding establishing Personnel Policy Committees in the PCSSD.

1.  What basis, rationale, policy, or other guidance are you using for establishing PPC's, particularly when you know PACT and PASS have met all of their obligations by law to be recognized as the collective bargaining  representative for both of these employee groups?

2.  What basis, rationale, policy, law, or other directive are you using to assume the current Professional Negotiated Agreements (PNA's) that were negotiated by and agreed to both parties can be ignored?

3.  Why would you take any action that would necessitate spending any funds in the courtroom not the classroom, particularly when you are publicly stating the district is in dire financial distress? What will this do to increase the capacity of any building level educator or student to improve their performance.  What is the "value" of this action in terms of money?  The morale and well being of your teacher and support staff?

4. What research or other data are you using that shows "non union" districts out perform those that are "union" represented?  In what ways does this appreciably improve teacher retention and job satisfaction? Student achievement? This is a particularly important question given the existence of a tremendous amount of data that seems to contradict that specific position.

By the way gentleman, I hope you don't mind if I ask you more questions as I learn more about the specifics about your budget and some rumored "contradictions" in one or more budget presentations that have been made. Please know I appreciate your time and assistance. Thank you!

 Respectfully,

Dave Wheeler

Please feel free to join me asking these two gentleman to clarify their position so we don't mistakenly assume their sole purpose is UNION BUSTING TOO! You can use and modify my questions or add some of your own!  In fact, feel free to share your questions or comments below.